LOTR vs Star Wars

ihatethunderbay · Post by **ihatethunderbay** » 9/17/2003, 6:50 pm

The HP books aren't bad at all. They're getting a lot less kiddy, which I like.

Johnny · Post by **Johnny** » 9/17/2003, 10:24 pm

I saw the HP movies a few week back, after reading the books I figured that I'd check out the shows. I enjoyed them :nod:

wanan · Post by **wanan** » 9/18/2003, 4:35 pm

I really like Harry Potter. The books are amazing. The movies are pretty good but don't compare to the books. Apparently they're thinking of filming Goblet of Fire as one movie and having an intermission half way through because it's so long.

Joey · Post by **Joey** » 9/18/2003, 5:45 pm

It's gonna suck though cuz apparently they may have to change the actors .. after seeing Harry, Hermi and Ron with these actors, changing characters for the rest of the series would suck :neutral:

This Harry is perfect :nod:

The actor that plays Draco said the 3rd movie was his last ...

Johnny · Post by **Johnny** » 9/18/2003, 7:14 pm

I read in People magazine that that Harry, Ron and Hermione(I dont know their names) are negoiations to do the fourth moive.

Joey · Post by **Joey** » 9/18/2003, 7:16 pm

That is excellant news :nod:

Though I will miss Draco .. he was hot .. young, but hot

Johnny · Post by **Johnny** » 9/18/2003, 7:19 pm

..just makes me wonder whose going to be playing Dumbledore now :think:

Joey · Post by **Joey** » 9/18/2003, 7:24 pm

I can't remember his name .. but they already cast him .. I wanted Ian from LOTR to do it but he turned it down .. at the time he was busy with XMen I believe but he would have been perfect .. though not as perfect as Richard Harris was

Johnny · Post by **Johnny** » 9/18/2003, 7:26 pm

I heard that Patrick Stewart was considered for the role.

Joey · Post by **Joey** » 9/18/2003, 7:34 pm

I don't know who that is :freak:

buzhwa · Post by **buzhwa** » 9/18/2003, 8:06 pm

LMAO - Patrick Stewart would make such a funny Dumbledore! They'd have to get him an enormous wig. Joey, he's Captain Picard from Star Trek: The Next Generation (and a lot of Star Trek movies, I think). I heard all kinds of rumors about the new Dumbledore, including Sean Connery!

*in "The Rock" voice* "Welcome to Hogwarts." :lol:

Anyway, the guy who's going to play Dumbledore is Sir Michael Gambon. In my view, he's never going to be able to replace Richard Harris, but the producers have done a decent job in recreating him (see http://i.imdb.com/Photos/Ss/0304141/C301-7.jpg).

Joey · Post by **Joey** » 9/18/2003, 8:11 pm

Ohhh ... the bald guy from Star Trek? :lol:

With all the beard and robes it will be hard to really tell the difference .. but I loved the voice of Dumbledore/Richard Harris and thought it was perfect so that's where I'll probably be disappointed with the new Dumbledore but we'll see! New director for the 3rd HP too so I hope not too much is different!

wanan · Post by **wanan** » 9/18/2003, 9:39 pm

Apparently, with a new director and actor, they're taking Dumbledore in a new direction. A bit more hippy-like I think.

By the way, I saw Patrick Stewart in a play once. He's an amazing actor, I'm sure he would have been good as Dumbledore. Maybe a different role in the future. They've used practically every name actor from England there is, so why not?

Random Name · Post by **Random Name** » 9/19/2003, 1:22 pm

I actually thought that the movies were no where near as good as the books. and that Dumbledore was a huge let down. The chamber really lost something in that movie. its wasnt the same.

but thats just me. I am all about the books.

And they are getting darker and better as they go on. I mean in the order Harry was all angstie and angry, not really something little kids are going to understand very well.

buzhwa · Post by **buzhwa** » 9/19/2003, 1:33 pm

Yeah, there are so many details in the books that the movies just can't measure up to.

Joey · Post by **Joey** » 9/19/2003, 5:04 pm

That's like all movies that are taken from books though .. I felt the same way with LOTR .. just too many details left out .. especially during the 2nd movie .. but still damn good .. I think the HP movies included a lot of detail from the books though .. that's just me. Especially since JK Rowling assisted in the script writing and everything had to be run by her first.

:drool:

robcore · Post by **robcore** » 9/19/2003, 6:02 pm

The one movie i've ever seen that was better than it's book was "of mice and men," but that's because it was like a 99 page novel (and the actors were simply amazing)