Hey, we have a new nominee for the "person most likely to make a thread that's already been made 3 times" category!
Anyways... At this point, I honestly wouldn't care if OLP broke up. I mean, if the whole band had split up when Mike left (or any time before), it would have been a tragedy. But now, I just don't see the band making anything that's really worth making. Sure, they'll gain their spot at the top of the charts, right along with Chad Choader and every other hit-of-the-moment bands and pop acts. But the fact of the matter is, they've lost everything that made them worth listening to. They were creative, insightful, meaningful, with a complexity that blended itself into simplicity (don't ask me to explain. Listen to SM passively; you get a simple CD with some great songs. Listen intently for what's there, and there's an orgasmic plethora of sounds.) Let's pretend for a moment that OLP broke up when Mike left. Then a new band came along, named Our Lad Pete. A song comes out of the radio "I know you're out there, somewhere out there." Tell me, would you really have run out to buy the CD, hoping to find a band that you can really feel at home with, or would you just buy it 'cause you kinda like it, or would you just ignore it all together? Without their first four albums, OLP are nothing. I think it's absolutely ridiculous for them to completely turn their backs on that. And it's not like they couldn't experiment with sound. I mean, listen to Naveed and then Clumsy; two completely different albums. Each of their albums had a fresh sound, and it was never repetitive. They could have easily given their style a rock twist without jumping head-over-heals into the atrocious poppy mush that became of Gravity. I think they made a big mistake with this. The only reason that I can see them preferring this route is because it's easier. It's easier to write "Walking in circles. Walking in circles. Walking in circles". It's easier to sing somewhat off-key, without experimenting with falsettos, or putting some emotion in your voice. It's easier to play a simple heavy drum beat than to craft a rhythmic section. And the worst of it all is that the band thinks the fans love it! That is, of course, because their main conception of “fans” is those who show up to their shows, singing along to the oh-so-challenging chorus of "Innocent". What they don't seem to realize is that these "fans" are the ones who just come and go, completely untouched by the music or the message. They think they're touching more lives this way. They're not. They're just becoming the passing fad in more lives. They've taken on a position of lessened respectability. They've taken on a position of lessened creativity. Most of all, they've taken on a position of lessened intelligence. Everything is dumbed down, and it sickens me.
Whew. I wasn't expecting that to come out. heh...