ClumsyMonkey.net

50. matthew good band - beautiful midnight
49. our lady peace - clumsy
48. death from above 1979 - you're a woman, i'm a machine
47. alanis morissette - jagged little pill
46. cowboy junkies - the trinity sessions
45. rufus wainwright - s/t
44. rheostatics - melville
43. feist - let it die
42. leonard cohen - songs of leonard cohen
41. sloan - navy blues
40. bryan adams - reckless
39. neil young - tonight's the night
38. billy talent - s/t
37. sam roberts - we were born in a flame
36. blue rodeo - outskirts
35. sarah harmer - you were here
34. nomeansno - wrong
33. superfriendz - mock up scale down
32. the trragicallly hip - up to here
31. thrust hermit - clayton park
30. the constantines - s/t
29. neil young - rust never sleeps
28. the guess who - american woman
27. the constantines - shine a light
26. eric's trip - love tara
25. metric - old world underground, where are you now?
24. neil young - everybody knows this is nowhere
23. hayden - everything i long for
22. blue rodeo - five days in july
21. the tragically hip - day for night
20. leonard cohen - songs of love and hate
19. sarah mclachlan - fumbling towards ecstasy
18. rush - moving pictures
17. the arcarde fire - funeral
16. sloan - smeared
15. rush - 2112
14. the band - music from big pink
13. sloan - one chord to another
12. the new pornographers - mass romantic
11. k-os - joyful rebellion
10. rheostatics - whale music
09. the band - the band
08. the tragically hip - fully completely
07. the lowest of the low - shakespeare my butt
06. weakerthans - left and leaving
05. neil young - after the gold rush
04. broken social scene - you forgot it in people
03. joni mitchell - blue
02. neil young - harvest
01. sloan - twice removed




hm.. discuss.

this list makes me want to buy like a bajilion cds NOW.

especially bss

death from above better than clumsy and beautiful midnight? hardly
and sloan shows up like 4 times on that list, and pesonally I don't think they are that great., where's Burton Cummings? or the Guess Who?

That really wasn't how I was expecting that list to be...

Stupid people

Sloan doesn't write the best singles but they do write complete albums better than any other band in Canada in my opinion.

Also, I think Jagged Little Pill should be higher along with MGB and OLP. Some of the newer albums were a little higher than you would think.

don't you guys know, the purpose of a top 50, 20, 30 list, is for the writer or the person who is making the list to credit THEIR fav bands, and obviously the person who did this one is a retard, and doesn't know that canadian music extends beyond Sloan, and Matthew Good,.

He put K-OS joyfull rebellion at number 11, and yes it was a very good cd, but at number 11 of all time? noppe

Sloan I can see being on there, but they have zero Tegan and Sara, so obviously this list is very messed up. Whats with Billy Talent

yeah, tegan and sara definitely do not belong on that list.

Yeah they do!

it's just one person's opinion. it means nothing to me, lol. i'm not a HUGE matt good fan, but beautiful midnight is really good and i don't see how it's number 50 whereas K-os and the weakerthans are under #20...

I've never heard any Sloan songs I don't think so I can't comment on them beating my favouritest album of all time (Harvest ). And Blue is also an amazing album. I think Beautiful Midnight should definitely have been higher than 50 though - sooooo much better than Billy Talent.

Me&MyOneManArmy wrote:where's ... the Guess Who?

no. 28

the Billy Talent album is pretty good though. Not one of the top 50 Canadian album sof all time though.
Why aren't the Who on this?

So can we all agree that we disagree?

For the record....i was beat out by both Sooz and Me and my one man army, i guess that's what happens when you leave a window open and then reply. kinda wierd that we were thinking the same thing though!

It would be better if they published a top 50 according to Canadian or North American album sales.

i commend this list for not having any Avril Lavigne...
and for having the balls to put the weakerthans in the top ten




otherwise i really dont like it at all.

aaaaaaand tegan and sara are probably better than a lot of what's on there.