I remember my first listen of Pardon Me... it was on Youtube, and I did not like it at ALL. I thought it was funny in a, "Wow, this is a terrible song" kind of way. Now that I have the album, I love it!
I don't have S.C.I.E.N.C.E. or Fungus Amongus or Enjoy Incubus. I've heard a few songs from that general era and didn't like it, but that was almost a year ago and I haven't tried since...
I think mine is:
Make Yourself > A Crow Left of the Murder... > Morning View > Light Grenades.
Light Grenades, from my very few listens, seems very... junky.
I don't think Light Grenades is nearly as bad as most Incubus fans make it out to be. Pendulous Threads, Rogues, and Paper Shoes are three absolutely awesome songs.
My favorite from MV is Echo. I actually just became obsessed with Incubus. I literally didn't listen to pretty much anything but them for a few months. I loved Agoraphobia from A crow..., I love the creepy feel to it and the lyrics. My album rank would probably look something like this
1. MV
2. Make yourself
3. Light Grenades
4. A crow left for murder
5. SCIENCE
6. FUngus Amungus
I actually don't mind Fungus. It's really funky. I think my only problem with it, is Brandon's screaming/not singing. But its different. ANd A Certain Shade of Green...Brilliant and Summer Romance. A few of my favorites.