Like the title says.
My votes are for As Fast as You Can, just cause it's an awesomely positive and solidly good song and.... Find Our Way
I must say that I think they absolutely must release Find Our Way as a single. The riff is absolutely killer, not to mention the breakdown. It shows off an almost Naveed-like raw side of OLP that a lot of longtime OLP listeners haven't heard a while so that would draw them in especialy if they've been a littl disillusioned with some of the singles they've been putting out in recent years. Also, that riff is something that any fan of rock or music in general can appreciate. It's catchy and unique- and I think it's those two traits that I think drew a lot of people to the band in the first place..
I think AFAYC would be great at attracting a really broad audience, with Find Our Way kinda covering the more hardcore crowd. That way, they kind of have something for everyone.
This is It I think would work well I think but if I had to choose- I think Find Our Way just edges it out based on the energy and riff alone. It's something fresh and energetic that the rock scene hasn't heard in a while. This is It is a great song, but it's less unique I feel and therefore less of a song that would make people feel like checking out the rest of the album.