We are penned in by the arrogant idea that this country is the center of the universe, exceptionally virtuous, admirable, superior.
No, I don't think most Americans believe that and yes, the Nazis are our "gold standard" of evil because they committed probably the most massive and senseless genocide ever.Most Americans firmly believe there is nothing the United States or its political leadership could possibly do that could equate to the crimes of Hitler's Third Reich. The Nazis are our "gold standard of evil," as author John Dolan once put it.
Wrong. Not just wrong, bullshit. Abu Gharib and Haditha can mainly be attributed to individuals committing acts that are perversions of American values. The destructions of Fallouja and Ramadi were part of a military campaign against armed enemy combatants. I'd also like to see an actual number there as opposed to "tens of thousands" of Iraqi deaths and maybe some indication of what percentage of those were accidental killings of civilians and how many were acts of war against armed enemy fighters.But the truth is that we can, and we have -- most recently and significantly in Iraq. It was the decision to invade Iraq in 2003 that made possible the horrors of Abu Ghraib, the destruction of Fallouja and Ramadi, the tens of thousands of Iraqi deaths, civilian massacres like Haditha, and on and on.
redneck_bill wrote:I
I've heard professional ethicists say that invading Iraq was the most noble thing the United States has done since it helped liberate Europe during World War II.
LifeRiot wrote: ...the fact that us being there is ten times worse then Saddams rule.
Democracy is the cure if Iraqis are willing to accept it.
xjsb125 wrote: Perhaps it would be better if we cleaned our own house first and then help the others who WANT our help to clean theirs as well.
xjsb125 wrote:Democracy is the cure if Iraqis are willing to accept it.
I think it's pretty obvious they aren't willing to accept it, and least not the total country. I think it's great that Saddam isn't in control over there anymore, however our presence there is only in an effort to keep us close to being in a controlling position of one of the worlds most used resources. The people of Iraq likely don't want our democracy and culture, they want their own culture and want to live how they want to, not how the US wants them to live. I also don't see how you can say that the US wants to promote peace, when we do so many things that contradict that. I see that there is a want for the rest of the world to live just like us. Perhaps it would be better if we cleaned our own house first and then help the others who WANT our help to clean theirs as well.
xjsb125 wrote:That's true, but it's what they want. They don't want a democracy, so why should it be forced on them?
LifeRiot wrote:That is pretty much Americas motto now
If you don't do what we want, we'll bring democracy to your country.
Korzic wrote:xjsb125 wrote:That's true, but it's what they want. They don't want a democracy, so why should it be forced on them?
I think you'll find (as per usual) it's the vocal (and mostly violent) minority that are objecting. If you asked your normal every day Iraqi what he thinks of democracy I'm sure he'd give it favourable reviews. It shouldn't be forced on them but I don't think that withdrawing now would be the wisest of moves.
Users browsing this forum: Majestic-12 [Bot] and 6 guests
Delete all board cookies • All times are UTC - 6 hours • PHPBB Powered
Serving Our Lady Peace fans since 2002. Oskar Twitch thanks you for tasting the monkey brains.