by Gadmo » 10/29/2017, 12:27 pm
I just got back from the show, so thought I'd post a review. The band sounded great, but unfortunately, there were some disappointments.
The disappointing:
1) The crowd was pretty lackluster. Most of the people on the floor appeared to not move a muscle for the entire length of the show, and the crowd-sing-along portions of the show were met with weak responses. The audience just didn't seem all that enthused to be there.
2) We didn't get the "Clumsy appreciation" show I'd hoped for, and the one they've been playing so far this tour. It was a much shorter show than others they've been playing, by four or five songs. When Raine introduced Big Dumb Rocket he did so by saying that they'd be playing a bunch of deeper cuts from Clumsy throughout the night, and then proceeded to play literally no more deeper cuts. The only other moderately deep cut from Clumsy we got was Automatic Flowers, which opened the show. The fact that we didn't get to hear Carnival, Story of 100 Aisles and Car Crash was a bummer.
3) Speaking of songs we missed out on, I think this may've been the first show I've seen since Happiness came out where One Man Army wasn't played. It's too bad - I love that song.
4) Rabbits is back. I know a lot people are fans of that song, but there's no OLP song I dislike more. Raine is a pretentious guy and that song is pretentiousness served up on a platter. No song brings the energy and momentum of the show to a screeching halt as much as that one does. The fact that the band used it as their opening song for the better part of five years was bad enough, but at least that way, they got it out of the way early. In the middle of a set, it's like they're telling the crowd, 'now's the time to use the bathroom - you have four minutes.'
5) Paper Moon/Life - I love both these songs, but Raine talk-singing one chorus of Life under the music for Paper Moon right at the very end of the song just reminds me that they aren't going to play Life. I'd rather they played Life.
6) No new (unreleased) songs. We didn't get to hear Ballad of a Poet or Head Down. I was excited to hear them and purposely avoided looking them up on youtube. Oh well.
The Good:
1) The band sounded great. Jason isn't Jeremy, and sounds like he has a bit of a sloppier style - specifically in the transition of Not Enough, but he was certainly competent and did a respectable job.
2) In Repair, complete with R.K. intro - totally unexpected and very welcome. I love that song. It sounded a bit more subdued than they've played it other times, but it was wonderful.
3) I know I did a lot of bitching about songs they didn't play, but the ones they did were outstanding. Opening with Automatic Flowers just put a huge smile on my face.
4) Nice to Meet You. If Somethingness Vol. 1 is divided into the good and the bad, Drop Me In The Water and Nice to Meet You would definitely be the good - (Hiding Place is a little too sappy? soft? weak? pretentious? (there's that word again) and Falling Into Place just hasn't fallen into place for me - maybe it'll grow on me, but not yet). Nice to Meet You hit me right away and it was great to hear.
5) Soundcheck - because of the venue, in order to secure a spot inside the show it's best to wait on line pretty early. As a result, we got to hear a soundcheck. Raine didn't participate, but hearing instrumental versions of Nice to Meet You, Big Dumb Rocket, Automatic Flowers and Is Anybody Home two hours before the show was a fun added bonus.
6) Starseed - I will never get sick of that song.
All in all, it was a really good, fun show, albeit a little too short, and with a crowd that could've used a RedBull.
The full setlist:
Automatic Flowers
Superman's Dead
Big Dumb Rocket
Innocent
Rabbits
Paper Moon (Life)
Is Anybody Home?
Somewhere Out There
Drop Me In The Water
Nice To Meet You
In Repair
Clumsy
Encore:
4am
Not Enough
Starseed